Jump to navigation

The University of Arizona Wordmark Line Logo White
Home
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  •  
  • Events
  • News
  • Publications
  • Programs
  • Resources
  • Opportunities
  • About
  • Give
Weekly Wave
  • Facebook  
  • Twitter  
  • YouTube  

Log In

A research and extension unit of the

College of Agriculture and Life Sciences

Engagement
January 28, 2022

Supreme Court to Hear WOTUS Case

On Monday the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) granted an appeal in Sackett v. EPA, a 2012 case involving federal jurisdiction to regulate wetlands on private land under the Clean Water Act (CWA). In the 2012 decision, SCOTUS sided with the Idaho landowners, ruling that the Sacketts have the right to challenge a CWA order from the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), but the court affirmed the lower court’s ruling that the wetland in question was under the jurisdiction of the CWA.
 
Fifteen years ago, Idaho residents Chantell and Michael Sackett filled in wetlands on their property to build a house. The project was halted by the EPA because the wetlands were considered Waters of the United States (WOTUS) under the CWA, and the Sacketts had not obtained a federal permit to build on the property. The Sacketts were faced with hefty fines and an order to remove the dirt they had used to fill the wetlands. Though SCOTUS ruled that the Sacketts had the right to sue the EPA, the court's affirmation that the wetlands were WOTUS under the CWA relied on precedent set by the 2006 landmark case, Rapanos v. United States. Now the Supreme Court has granted a review of the 2012 decision relating to the definition of WOTUS under the CWA. In Rapanos the court issued a 4-1-4 decision, establishing two tests to determine whether a wetland is considered WOTUS under the CWA. Former Justice Anthony Kennedy, the swing vote in Rapanos, established a test that defined a wetland as any body of water with a “significant nexus” to a larger body of water. This broad view of what constituted a wetland is at odds with the test established by Former Justice Antonin Scalia in his opinion, which states that WOTUS should only include permanent, standing, or continuously flowing bodies of water.
 
Justice Kennedy’s test was used by the Obama Administration to inform the 2015 Clean Water Rule, while the Trump Administration’s 2020 Navigable Waters Protection Rule used Justice Scalia’s test to gut the Clean Water Rule. After an Arizona court struck down the Navigable Waters Protection Rule in 2020, the Biden Administration announced their intention to develop a new rule, a process now being thrown into question by the Supreme Court. The outcome of this case could resolve some of the uncertainty stemming from the split Rapanos decision and if the court adopts Justice Scalias’ test, significantly limit the jurisdictional scope of the CWA. 

Reuters Article
Greenwire Article

Recent News

June 24, 2022
Annual Coconino County 4th Grade Water Ethics Contest

Water conservation is an ethical challenge. Integrating ethical water education into our programs instills a sense of stewardship, ownership, and responsibility in our youth, shaping behaviors and inspiring solutions to our water resource issues. Each year, 4th-grade students across Coconino County are invited to participate in a Water Ethics Contest. The contest, which began in 2010, is sponsored by the Coconino Plateau Watershed Partnership (a branch of the Coconino Plateau Water Advisory Council) and hosted by Willow Bend Environmental Education Center.

Read More
Engagement
June 24, 2022
Quick! Register Now for the WRRC Annual Conference!

The low-cost standard registration for the WRRC's upcoming conference, Arizona’s Agricultural Outlook: Water, Climate, and Sustainability, closes on June 30! Register today to ensure your spot before the price goes up. In addition to the diverse set of speakers and topics scheduled for the in-person day on July 12, the WRRC has organized two days of virtual programming on July 13 and 14.

Read More
Education
June 09, 2022
BOOK REVIEW - The Water Recycling Revolution: Tapping into the Future

Summer break is a good time for reading. Although fiction is my preferred genre, I was eager to read the fourth and latest book by William M. and Rosemarie Alley, The Water Recycling Revolution: Tapping into the Future

Read More
Engagement
May 31, 2022
WRRC and Universidad de Sonora: Present and Future Cooperation on Transboundary Matters

On May 16, the WRRC organized a meeting in Nogales, Arizona to discuss current and future opportunities for collaboration on the federally funded Transboundary Aquifer Assessment Program (TAAP). 

Read More
Image of a plant sprout beside an image of water
May 26, 2022
Agriculture/Water Nexus Academy 2022

Water is an important consideration for most businesses, but it is absolutely essential for agriculture. Arizona agriculture exports food and fiber to 70 countries across the globe as well as throughout the US. 

Read More
May 25, 2022
Many Engaged for INHABITANTS Documentary Panel Discussion

On May 16, the WRRC hosted a panel discussion on the documentary film INHABITANTS: Indigenous Perspectives On Restoring Our World. The panel featured Dr. Michael Kotutwa Johnson, Assistant Specialist, UArizona Indigenous Resilience Center, School of Natural Resources and the Environment; film co-directors Costa Boutsikaris and Anna Palmer; and moderator Rebecca Tsosie, JD, Regents Professor of Law, UArizona James E. Rogers College of Law.

Read More
  • Show More

We tackle key water policy and management issues, empower informed decision-making, and enrich understanding through engagement, education, and applied research.

Give Today
Weekly Wave

Keep up with our news and events with a subscription to our Weekly Wave.

Subscribe

Reach Out

  • 350 N Campbell Ave
    Tucson, AZ 85719
  • (520) 621-9591
  • (520) 792-8518
  • Email Us
  • Directory

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

© 2022 The Arizona Board of Regents on behalf of The University of Arizona.